|
Should students learn cursive writing in school? Teachers, you decide after reading the advantages and disadvantages of students learning cursive writing.
Schools in Canada and the United States introduce students to cursive writing in the primary grades. Montessori schools have students learn cursive writing in kindergarten and allow block printing to develop in later years. As a teacher, I understand the restrictions of time to teach all the fundamentals, but why has cursive writing become a forgotten subject.
Cursive writing is a beautiful art form that connects the letters with swoops and curls. It is an art form that is unique to each individual student. No two handwritten letters are the same even though each word written is identical. Cursive writing speaks about the student's personality and the type of day they are experiencing.
Should we keep teaching kids cursive writing in public schools? Teachers you decide.
Advantages of Learning Cursive Writing
- Cursive is faster than printing
- More efficient for taking notes
- Able to write without the use of technology
- Art form to display a student's inner feelings and thoughts
- Easier for students to learn cursive than printing
- Develop fine motor skills
- Writing in journals, handwriting in sync with the students flow of thought
- Hand written apology more meaningful than one generated on a word document
- Personalize Letters
Disadvantages of Learning Cursive Writing
As a teacher, my personal view is for kids to learn cursive writing for the reasons listed in the advantages column. It does take time and some kids become frustrated with the process but I believe it is worth the effort for kids to learn a beautiful art form. If time is restrictive, have students learn cursive writing during art class, as the beauty of the lines is definitely an aspect of art.
The copyright of the article Cursive Writing For Kids in Teacher Tips/Training is owned by Debbie DeSpirt. Permission to republish Cursive Writing For Kids in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.
Comments
Apr 28, 2008 10:04 AM
Guest :
Another advantage - on college entrance tests, oftentimes students have to
copy a passage in cursive, as I found out to my distress, having forgotten
most of the cursive letters except those in my name. That's another thing -
many people sign in cursive!
May 9, 2008 7:12 AM
Guest :
typing is coming upon us
May 14, 2008 10:14 PM
Guest :
I'm sixty years old and I stumbled into this cursive site because my
handwriting is clumsy block letters. I learned cursive in grade school but
gravitated towards block. My Mom had beautiful script and I thought I
would now learn it as art form and daily gift to myself and my family. To
often kids don't practice life art, art that they will used every day for
the rest of their life. I don't regret any choice I ever made (couldn't
change it anyway) but I can correct a mistake and share penship all the
rest of my life. Surely the value of a mindful cursive writer wielding a
simple pencil must be vastly superior to a keyboard writer suddenly without
technology. Clarity and purpose in a handwritten document is apparent. A
mindfully written and beautifully presented handwritten document includes a
glimpse of the emotion of the writer. A handwritten letter transmits
far more information in far fewer words. All upsets are caused by a lack
of communication. Mindful cursive reaches to the core the human experience
and offers endless gifts that last generations. If you are an adult look
at a sample of your parents or grandparents handwriting and see if that
doesn't evoke more than a typed letter might from you to your kids. Give
the kids a life gift, teach them to really communicate how they feel and
let all of us reap the rich rewards for generations to come.
Aug 27, 2008 7:25 AM
Guest :
Hi, I have been homeschooling for 1 1/2 Yrs now. I had decided not to
teach cursive to, my G'son likes to print. My husband prefers printing and
I thought about it and decided, back then, to let him print. One day I
haded him a paper and asked him to read this to me, please. I think I was
bust doing something and thought nothing of asking him to read it for me.
He handed it back to me and said, "Granny I can't read this." I
asked him why & he told me, "It is in cursive."
Hearing him tell me he could not read this paper told me, I NEED to teach
him cursive. I would not let him go threw life not knowing how to read
printed penmanship and I will not let him tell me now. He needs to at least
know how to read cursive and to do that, I need to teach him to write it.
Later in life, print or not, I don't mind which he uses but
knowing how gives him the choice!
My new out look on not
teaching cursive writing. Whether he uses it or not, he needs to be able to
read it!
Oct 17, 2008 1:58 PM
Guest :
One problem I would like to suggest is that most of the books that children
read are all manuscript. Students in the first and second grade often
cannot identify cursive letters. If they learn cursive first, learning to
read will be more difficult.
Nov 13, 2008 12:23 PM
Guest :
It is often hard enough to get children to enjoy creative writing--and I
think that process is more important than how it is written. Boys in
particular seem to find cursive time consuming, and then they don't want to
write at all. In addition, seems silly to spend too much time on something
our children will spend little time doing in their adult life in the 21st
century.
Dec 1, 2008 1:45 PM
Guest :
It is totally a waste of time the only reason for learning cursive is for a
signature. I found that recently people find it difficult to write faster
in cursive than in print considering that print is better known by people.
This "art" is different every time but i think kids need to only
learn to read it so if someone send them a typed invatation or something.
Another thing is that we have computers now and all we have to do is type
it highlight it and change the font.
Feb 28, 2009 5:29 PM
Guest :
it takes like a month or 2 to learn cursive, well and then you can remember
it for life
Mar 11, 2009 8:23 AM
Guest :
Cursive is pointless. Why have two ways to write the same thing? I can
write in block just as quickly as I can in cursive and it is much more
legible. The content should express your thoughts/emotions,not the writing
style. If that's a legitimate argument, why not have kids paint everything
so it can be as colorful and expressive as possible.
Cursive is
dead. Let it go.
Mar 16, 2009 9:33 AM
Guest :
I am an occupational therapist working with preschool to post-highschool
students. Children in the U.S. are being short changed in the neglect of
handwriting. Handwriting is a valuable cultural endeavor for much more
than aesthetic reasons alone. My take on handwriting is this - requiring
kindergarteners to write is silly; at least a third of them don't have the
fine motor or attentional skills to do so with good form, and many of them
develop very bad habits that are carried over throughout their life. The
idea of teaching cursive prior to print may have merit. Print and cursive
are crucial parts of any school's curriculum because of this: It provides
a micro gymnasium for the body and mind. Even though writing a letter
occurs in a very small space, it requires a complex integration of
movement, pressure, and visual processing. Angular, straight, and circular
movements are all sequenced in a specific order to imitate fairly complex
visual images and motoric movements. This activity provides an organizing
foundation for the central nervous system that other skills can be
integrated with. The visual spatial and coordinative skills that develop
with a highly structured handwriting curriculum provide a neural structure
for organizing other kinds of information and skills. Research shows that
students perform higher in all subject areas when they participate in a
fully developed handwriting curriculum. Unfortunately, curriculums across
the U.S. are so crammed with peripheral content and schools spend so much
time doing and teaching things that families should be responsible for,
many gradeschools do not have formal handwriting curriculums. The idea
that handwriting is no longer necessary because of technology is incorrect.
When I look at my parent's handwriting and then my grandparent's
handwriting I can see the unfortunate cultural decline from a time when
people took pride in their handwriting, and took the time to make it a
beautiful thing. Maybe somehow this idea can be ushered back into modern
society, but right now I don't see that happening.
Apr 13, 2009 6:39 PM
Guest :
I learned how to learn cursive of the age at least 9 or 8 and I have to say
cursive is better than printing. I have been complimented by alot of people
who think I have good hand writing. I think kids should learn to write to
script because it is easier and makes writing easy and you can write with
it quickly if you are aexpert like me.
11 Comments
|